International media coverage of the Hong
Kong protests is wildly distorted, independent data researchers say.
And the result? As I write this, guerrilla
groups of vandals, financed by the US (evidence below), have shut down the
metro train station and the buses. My
wife and children are on the phone, unable to get to where they need to be.
A crowd of blameless Hong Kong people are
stranded at the nearby bus stop, some tearful with frustration. Children are
trapped on public buses: they can’t get to school and they can’t get home.
And the Western media? They have already
started applauding.
SOMETHING BAD IS HAPPENING
The truth: Coverage of Hong Kong is
motivated by anti-Chinese sentiment, in both right-leaning outlets like Fox
News and left-leaning outlets like the New York Times, the findings from a UK
group clearly show.
The result is the chaos and misery I see
all around me this morning. Many of my co-workers have crucial deadlines to
meet: all our livelihoods are at risk.
Who’s at fault? Skewed media coverage has
been encouraging violent radicals and hobbling attempts to deal with them. Hong
Kong’s careful, non-lethal ways of trying to stop the violence has received
unprecedented amounts of negative coverage from Western journalists—while the
documented brutal killing of hundreds of protesters all over the world has
received little or no coverage or at all.
SOME NUMBERS
An October 25 search for “Hong Kong
protests” over a single month produced 282 responses in the New York Times—but
“Chile protests” produced just 20, reported Alan MacLeod of the Glasgow
University Media Group.
“The unequal coverage is even more
pronounced on Fox News, where there were 70 results for Hong Kong over the same
period and four, two and three for Chile, Ecuador and Haiti respectively,” he
wrote in a summary of his findings for Salon.
The huge discrepancy cannot be explained
away by “news value”. Hong Kong protests have produced no direct killings, no
army call-out, no coups or martial law—while other anti-government protests
have been far more brutal, with hundreds of deaths in Iraq alone.
TERRIFIED RESEARCHER
“Western journalists are guilty of gross
dereliction of duty,” says one Hong Kong university researcher who will not
give her name because of the very real danger of her office being smashed up—an
incident that she believes no Western reporter would cover.
“What are all those people at the Foreign
Correspondents’ Club doing?” she asks. “Will not one reporter tell the truth
about Hong Kong?”
So far, she’s right. The real story, which
no Western reporter will touch, is that “the Hong Kong has won the war to
maintain stability,” says Tom Guendert, a Hong Kong based commentator. “The
Hong Kong dollar has not been devalued, and Kyle Bass’s campaign to scare
institutional investors has failed.” Importantly, “direct police action
casualties have been avoided.”
Why will no one print that?
MISLEADING THE WORLD
Looking at the hard data, it is difficult
to avoid the conclusion that foreign correspondents are grossly misleading the
global public.
The Western media continuously conflates
the violent radicals demanding to “liberate Hong Kong from China” with the
actual majority residents of Hong Kong, who in truth want the exact opposite:
they don’t want independence from mainland China, but want a positive
relationship.
The media also conflates the Hong Kong
civil service with Beijing, and Hong Kong’s imperfect but generally non-corrupt
police force with China’s very different PLA.
PROOF OF FUNDING
Western news outlets automatically pour
scorn on suggestions that the protesters receive funding from the United
States—despite the fact that an internet search taking literally 0.02 seconds
will give any interested party the truth.
US$22 million has been sent to unnamed
persons for efforts to promote Western-style democracy in mainland China and
Hong Kong since 2014 by the National Endowment for Democracy, as MacLeod points
out.
A significant portion has gone to unnamed
activists in Hong Kong: it’s right there in print to anyone who can use
Google—and is honest enough to tell the truth.
BLATANT BIAS
The media bias is often stunning. The UK
Guardian labels self-described pro-democracy campaigners in Ecuador as
“rioters” but avoids using that word to describe Hong Kong protesters who are
clearly and unmistakably filmed in the act of rioting.
Why such gross distortion?
China is seen as the enemy of the West, so
anyone fighting China is painted as a hero—even when what they are really doing
is firebombing the offices of Hong Kong civil servants, a gentle, largely
female group of milky-tea drinkers who are often more British than the British.
WHO ARE THE VICTIMS?
The result is that the self-labelled
“silent majority”, which includes a significant section of the Hong Kong
public, plus the civil service, the police and so on, may actually be the real
victims – but the Western media won’t cover that angle as it doesn’t fit the
anti-China narrative.
“They will show far less enthusiasm for a
story when the ‘wrong’ people are the villains or the victims,” says MacLeod.
“The New York Times even invented the
phrase ‘aggressive nonviolence’ to describe the Hong Kong protesters’ actions,
so eager was it to frame the demonstrations against China as unquestionably
laudable.”
MARCH THAT NEVER WAS
A particularly egregious example is the
infamous “two million people” march in Hong Kong in June.
Scientists say it never happened. All the
scientific ways of measuring crowd-flow show that hundreds of thousands of
people marched, but not one million, let alone two. And any reporter with an
ounce of self-respect knows that “organizers’ claims” are pure fantasy.
Yet Western reporters silence their
fact-checkers to present fantastic claims as fact. Why? I know some of these
people. They’re not evil. They’re just extremely eager to believe the worst
against people they've decided are bad guys and the best of any group which
opposes them, even if some members are bigoted vandals throwing firebombs.
TRUTH CAMPAIGN
If the international media has abandoned
the Hong Kong people, how can we get the real story out?
There have been lots of ideas, such as
letter-writing campaigns to newspapers, or the patient countering of propaganda
with real facts.
It’s difficult. As this writer has found
out, any attempt to give a more nuanced picture of what’s happening in Hong
Kong leads to multiple accusations of being a “paid CCP stooge”.
KEEP THE FAITH
But we mustn’t give up. I got up early and
got to work before the protesters barricaded the roads.
I’ve just heard on the phone that some
co-workers at the publishing company I’m working at this morning are going to
walk the whole route.
Some local residents are going to meet and
dismantle the barricades, especially ones trapping school buses.
That’s the local spirit. We need to stay
strong. Keep smiling. If people place obstacles in our way, metaphorically or
literally, we'll patiently move them. Anyone who bets against the people of
Hong Kong will lose.
Peace.
From Nury Vittachi, who works at Poly University.